Email Segmentation for eCommerce: The Klaviyo Segments to Build First
How an eCommerce store should segment its email list, the six Klaviyo segments to build first, the conditions for each, and who to leave out of campaigns.

On this page
- What does email segmentation mean for an eCommerce store?
- Why does segmentation make more money than sending to everyone?
- How do Klaviyo segment conditions work?
- Which Klaviyo segments should a store build first?
- Which segments should you keep out of campaigns?
- Where does RFM fit in?
- Should you use a segment or a flow?
- What does segmentation look like with real numbers?
- When does this advice not apply?
- How does Hayes Media build segmentation for clients?
- Sources
Segment your email list by what people have done: whether they engage, whether they've bought, how often, how recently, and how much. In Klaviyo, build six segments first: engaged subscribers, subscribers who've never bought, first-time buyers, repeat buyers, lapsed buyers, and high-value customers. Hayes Media, an eCommerce growth agency for DTC and Shopify brands, builds Klaviyo segmentation this way, sends each segment its own message, and keeps people who never engage out of campaigns.
What does email segmentation mean for an eCommerce store?
Email segmentation means splitting your list into groups of people who've done similar things, so each group gets email that fits where they are with your brand. For a store, the most useful groups come from behaviour: clicks, site visits, and orders. Location and profile details help too, but what someone has bought tells you more than where they live.
Klaviyo draws a clear line between lists and segments. Its getting started guide says "Lists are static, meaning they grow as people subscribe or are manually added." Segments work differently: "Segments, on the other hand, are dynamic, meaning they grow as people meet the segments' conditions and shrink as people no longer meet them." So you build a segment once, and people move in and out of it as they buy, click, or go quiet.
One detail catches a lot of stores out. Klaviyo says a segment "will pull from all of the contacts in your account," which means a segment doesn't check consent on its own. Its persona guide puts it plainly: "List membership alone does not confirm email consent." Every segment you send campaigns to needs the condition If someone can or cannot receive marketing, set to can receive email marketing, with the Subscribed filter added, joined to the rest with AND.
Why does segmentation make more money than sending to everyone?
Because people buy when the email matches what they need next, and because inbox providers watch how people react to your email. A new arrivals email lands differently with someone who's bought from you five times than with someone who signed up for a code and never used it.
Klaviyo has published one figure on this. Its help page on segments says: "In Klaviyo’s analysis of emails sent by US-based customers from October through December 2017, highly segmented campaigns returned more than 3 times the revenue per recipient of unsegmented campaigns." That's Klaviyo's own data from a single holiday quarter in 2017, so treat it as a direction, not a forecast for your store.
The deliverability side matters just as much. Klaviyo's never engaged guide says "Regularly sending to profiles who don't engage with your emails can cause providers (e.g., Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook) to start placing your emails in spam." Sending to people who never open or click can drag down delivery for the people who do want to hear from you.
How do Klaviyo segment conditions work?
Every segment is a set of conditions joined with AND or OR. Klaviyo's segment conditions reference lists the main types, and these are the ones a store uses most:
What someone has done (or not done). Actions such as Placed Order, Opened Email, Clicked Email, or Viewed Product, counted over a timeframe.
Properties about someone. Profile details such as Country, First Active, or custom properties you've collected, like a product preference from a quiz.
If someone can or cannot receive marketing. Consent for each channel: email, SMS, or push.
Predictive analytics about someone. Klaviyo's predicted values, including customer lifetime value, if your account qualifies.
For actions, you pick a frequency and a timeframe. Frequency options include "At least once", "Zero times", "Equals", and "Is at least". Timeframe options include "Over all time", "In the last", "Between", and "At least", the last of which means at least a set number of hours, days, or weeks ago.
The connector changes who gets in. Klaviyo explains that "The AND connector between conditions will make a segment more exclusive and more strict," while OR "makes the segment more inclusive and less strict." Take extra care with negative conditions joined by OR. Klaviyo's own example is a segment meant to exclude the US and Canada that ends up including every country in the world.
What about the windows, like how recent counts as recent? You choose them. Klaviyo says "The definitions of recent, frequent, and monetary value should be customized for your business." A store selling coffee and a store selling mattresses have very different gaps between orders. The best way to set your windows is to look at how long your own customers take to place a second order, which our guide to ecommerce cohort analysis shows you how to read.
Which Klaviyo segments should a store build first?
Start with these six. Each one uses conditions every Shopify store already has, because they run on order and email data that syncs to Klaviyo. Add the email consent condition to each one before you send a campaign to it.
Engaged subscribers. Conditions: Clicked Email at least once in the last window you choose, OR Opened Email at least once in that window, OR Placed Order at least once in that window. Opens need care. Klaviyo notes that Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates open rates and says "To exclude MPP opens from engagement-based segments, filter each Opened Email condition so that Apple Privacy Open is false." This segment is the default audience for your regular campaigns.
Never purchased. Conditions: Placed Order zero times over all time. These people signed up but haven't bought. Klaviyo's persona guide says of engaged subscribers who've never bought: "Your goal is to nudge them over the line to make their first purchase by giving them a good reason to buy." Send them reviews, bestsellers, and answers to the questions that stop a first order. Your welcome series email does the first part of this job automatically.
First-time buyers. Conditions: Placed Order equals 1 over all time. Loyalty is earned across the whole buying experience, before and during the first order, and the second order is where it shows in your numbers. Send first-time buyers how to use what they bought, what goes with it, and a clear reason to come back. Our guide to repeat purchase rate explains how to measure whether that's working.
Repeat buyers. Conditions: Placed Order is at least 2 over all time. Klaviyo uses this exact example in its conditions reference: "you can find all customers that have made at least 2 purchases." Send them new arrivals, restocks, early access, and your loyalty program if you have one. Test full-price sends here before you reach for a discount.
Lapsed buyers. Conditions: Placed Order at least once over all time, AND Placed Order zero times in the last window you choose. Set that window a little past your normal gap between orders, so you're not chasing people who simply aren't due yet. Send them what's new since their last order, and run a winback email flow for the automated side.
High-value customers. If your account qualifies for predictive analytics, use Predictive analytics about someone with Historic Customer Lifetime Value above an amount you choose. If it doesn't, use Placed Order with the Revenue filter, which Klaviyo says is "based on the value of the Placed order or equivalent event synced through your integration." Klaviyo's persona guide says of its best customers, which it calls High rollers: "You don't necessarily need to discount aggressively, but other perks and exclusivity go a long way." Send them early access, first pick of limited runs, and a personal note from the founder.
Which segments should you keep out of campaigns?
Keep people who never engage out of your regular campaigns. Klaviyo's guide to a never engaged segment gives its manual definition, joined with AND: Person can receive email marketing, Person has Received Email is at least 5 in the last 180 days, and zero Opened Email, Clicked Email, and Placed Order events over all time. That's Klaviyo's suggested definition. You can adjust it, and Klaviyo suggests "excluding them from your marketing initiatives, sending them one final re-engagement attempt, or suppressing them during list cleaning."
Two more exclusions are worth setting up. Leave recent buyers out of discount campaigns, so someone who paid full price yesterday doesn't get a code today. And leave anyone in an active winback or welcome flow out of campaigns that would compete with it.
Where does RFM fit in?
RFM stands for recency, frequency, and monetary value: how recently someone bought, how often, and how much they spend. The six segments above are a simple version of it. Klaviyo's persona guide builds a fuller set with names like "High rollers" and "Lapsed high rollers", and gives a useful rule for weighting them: "Recency is more powerful than frequency." Once the basic six are running and you have enough customers in each, a full RFM grid is the next step.
Should you use a segment or a flow?
Use a segment for one-off campaigns and a flow for messages triggered by an action. Klaviyo says "Segments are great tools to identify cross-sections of your audience to send one-time campaigns to. You can also build a flow triggered when someone is added to a segment."
Know how timing works before you build a flow off a segment. Klaviyo explains that "If the passage of time alone causes a profile to qualify or no longer qualify, they are added or removed once every 24 hours." So a lapsed buyer segment updates once a day, not the moment someone crosses your window. It also notes that "A condition such as “Placed Order zero times” does not itself trigger that flow." Our guide to Klaviyo email flows covers which flows to run alongside your segments, and our article on the best time to send email covers when to schedule the campaigns.
What does segmentation look like with real numbers?
A worked example, with made-up numbers. Northfield Coffee, a made-up store, has 40,000 subscribers who can receive email. It sends one new blend email to everyone and makes $6,000. That's $0.15 revenue per recipient.
Next month it splits the same launch three ways. Repeat buyers, 3,000 people, get the launch at full price and spend $2,400, which is $0.80 per recipient. Engaged subscribers who've never bought, 9,000 people, get the launch with reviews and a brewing guide and spend $1,800, which is $0.20 per recipient. Never engaged profiles, 10,000 people, get nothing. The remaining 18,000 get one shorter email and spend $2,700, which is $0.15 per recipient.
Total revenue is $6,900 from 30,000 sends, against $6,000 from 40,000 sends the month before. Northfield made more money, sent 10,000 fewer emails, and stopped mailing the people most likely to hurt its delivery. Judge your own tests the same way: revenue per recipient by segment, plus unsubscribes and spam complaints.
When does this advice not apply?
If your list is small, splitting it six ways leaves segments too small to learn from. Start with engaged and never engaged, then add buyer segments as you grow. Predicted lifetime value also has entry rules: Klaviyo says you'll only see it if, among other things, "At least 500 customers have placed an order."
If you sell something people buy once, the repeat and lapsed segments matter less. Put more effort into the never purchased and first-time buyer segments, and into your post-purchase emails.
If you're not on Klaviyo, the logic still works, but the condition names will differ. Check that your platform can group people by orders and email engagement before you plan your segments.
How does Hayes Media build segmentation for clients?
Hayes Media builds segments, flows, and campaigns as one system in Klaviyo, and judges the work on what it adds to lifetime gross profit to CAC.
Hayes Media's retention practice covers email, SMS, loyalty programs, and subscribe-and-save. We work in Klaviyo for most accounts and have experience in most other email and SMS platforms, so a brand on another tool is still a fit. Email on its own is a complete engagement. On email.hayesmedia.co, Hayes says it's "Trusted by 50+ eCom brands" and lists "$500M+" in client revenue driven and "15x" average ROI. Those figures are published by Hayes on its own site, and Hayes has no third-party review profile and no Klaviyo partner listing, so weigh them as our own account of our work.
We typically work with brands doing at least $100K per month in revenue. It's a guideline, not a gate. A smaller brand with a clear budget set aside to scale and real order volume can still be a fit. One-time email projects start from $2,000 USD, and retainers for ongoing full management start from $4,000 USD per month, scoped on the discovery call. The email and SMS service page covers how we run a program.
If you're sending most campaigns to your whole list, a discovery call gets you an audit of your Klaviyo segments, your exclusions, and your campaign targeting, with what to fix first. No onboarding fees. No lock-in contracts. No junior marketers. Book a discovery call
Sources
Klaviyo, Getting started with segments: https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005237908
Klaviyo, Segment conditions reference: https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005062847
Klaviyo, How to create customer persona segments based on activity: https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000407272
Klaviyo, How to create a never engaged segment: https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005078347
Klaviyo, How to segment by customer lifetime value (CLV): https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/360013201072
Klaviyo, Understanding how segments update: https://help.klaviyo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005233488
Hayes Media retention figures and terms: https://email.hayesmedia.co/
Frequently asked questions
- What does email segmentation mean in eCommerce?
- Email segmentation is splitting your email list into groups based on what people have done, such as whether they've bought, how often, how recently, and whether they open or click your emails. Each group then gets campaigns that fit where they are with your brand. For a store, behaviour from orders and email activity is usually more useful than profile details like location.
- Which Klaviyo segments should I build first?
- Start with six: engaged subscribers, subscribers who've never bought, first-time buyers, repeat buyers, lapsed buyers, and high-value customers. Each one runs on order and email data that already syncs to Klaviyo from Shopify. Add a never engaged segment too, so you can keep those profiles out of your regular campaigns, and add the email consent condition to every segment you send to.
- How do I decide what counts as an engaged or lapsed customer?
- You set the windows for your own store. Klaviyo says the definitions of recent, frequent, and monetary value should be customized for your business. Look at how long your customers usually take to place a second order, then set your lapsed window a little past that gap. A store selling consumables will use a much shorter window than one selling furniture.
- What's the difference between a list and a segment in Klaviyo?
- A list is static. It grows when people subscribe or when you add them by hand. A segment is dynamic. It's defined by conditions, and people join or leave it automatically as they meet or stop meeting those conditions. Segments don't check consent on their own, so add the condition that a person can receive email marketing before you send a campaign.
- Does Hayes Media set up email segmentation for brands?
- Yes. Hayes Media builds segments, flows, and campaigns in Klaviyo as one system for eCommerce brands, and works on most other email platforms too. Its retention practice covers email, SMS, loyalty programs, and subscribe-and-save. One-time email projects start from $2,000 USD, and retainers for ongoing full management start from $4,000 USD per month, scoped on the discovery call.
Want this run for your brand?
Hayes Media builds direct response creative, buys the media, and runs the email & SMS behind it.
Book a discovery call

