How to Handle Sales Objections on High-Ticket Coaching Calls

What to say on a coaching sales call when a prospect raises price, timing, a partner or "I need to think about it", and what to fix before the call.

Jordan HayesJordan Hayes10 min read
A laptop showing a blank video call layout with grey placeholder tiles sits on a wooden desk beside a navy headset, an open blank lined notebook with a pen, and a coffee mug on a cork coaster, with blurred plants and a bookshelf behind.
On this page

For price, timing, or "I need to think about it", Hayes Media's advice is to acknowledge the objection, ask one question, answer the real concern, and agree next steps. Then fix the step before the call that should have brought that objection out earlier. Hayes Media is an agency that builds email and SMS systems, and this guide is for coaches selling high-ticket programs.

Two terms first. Close rate is sales divided by calls attended. Show rate is calls attended divided by calls booked. Objections affect close rate. They're the reasons people who turned up and heard the offer didn't buy. This piece covers what to say when an objection comes up and which earlier step to fix. The questions to ask before you present the offer are in our guide to discovery call questions for coaches, and what to send after a call that didn't close is in our guide to follow-up emails after a sales call.

What is a sales objection?

It's the reason a prospect gives for not buying yet. HubSpot's objection handling guide defines it as "a concern a prospect raises that prevents them from buying or advancing in the sales process." The same guide adds: "Most sales objections sound straightforward, but they're usually not."

On a coaching call, the concern is personal. The person is spending their own money on themselves, giving up their own time, and deciding whether they believe they can do it. So "it's too expensive" can be about the amount, about whether it'll work for them, or about who else gets a say at home.

Where do objections on a coaching call come from?

Each common objection maps to a question that could have been asked before the call. If price is a surprise at the end, nothing before the call set an expectation about the investment. If a partner appears at the end, nobody asked who else decides. If they need to think about it, check whether anyone told them the call ends with a decision.

That's why Hayes Media pairs every objection with an upstream fix: the application form, the pre-call emails, or the discovery questions. HubSpot's framework starts with a similar idea, a step called anticipate that happens before any call. The guide also says "the biggest obstacle to overcoming objections is answering the stated objection instead of the real one." When the earlier steps do their job, the prospect arrives knowing the price range and how the call ends, and you already know what they've tried and who decides.

How do you handle an objection on the call?

Use four moves, in order: acknowledge it, ask one question, answer the real concern, and agree what happens next. HubSpot describes a similar loop of listen, acknowledge, explore, and respond, which it credits to Carew International as LAER.

Acknowledge it. Say it back without arguing: "That's a fair thing to weigh." HubSpot quotes Laura Youngblom, who says that "when you disagree, you stop the flow of communication, but when you agree, their defenses come down."

Ask one question. "Can I ask what part of it is giving you pause?" Then stop talking and let them answer in full.

Answer the real concern. Answer only what they told you, in plain words, using what they said earlier in the call. If you can't honestly answer it, say so.

Agree the next step. A yes, a no, or a booked time to talk again. HubSpot's advice is direct: "If a prospect needs time, give them space, but pin down a concrete next step before the call ends."

Below is the wording for five common objections, each paired with the step to fix before the call.

What do you say when they say it's too expensive?

On the call: Find out which kind of price objection it is. Shopify's guide to sales objections splits budget objections in two: people who truly can't afford it, and people who have the money but aren't sure it's worth the price. Of the first group, it says: "Pushing this type of shopper toward a purchase is irresponsible."

So ask: "Is it the total amount, or whether it's worth it for you?" If it's the value, play back the goal they described and what it's costing them now, then show which parts of the program get them there. If it's the amount, share any payment options you already offer. If they can't afford it, tell them now isn't the right time. Don't cut the price to save the sale, because then the first price stops meaning anything.

Fix it upstream: Add a budget question with ranges to your application form, or say in the pre-call email that the call covers the investment. Then the number on the call is one they expected.

What do you say when they need to think about it?

On the call: Agree, then ask what they want to think through. Rakhi Oswal, founder of EDRIO, is quoted in Shopify's guide on this exact objection: "Begin your response with 'No problem' to put them at ease." Then try: "No problem. So I can help, what's the part you want to think through?" The answer gives you a specific concern, such as price, timing, or a partner, and you can answer that one. If they still want time, book a day and time to talk again before you hang up.

Fix it upstream: Tell them how the call ends before they join. In the pre-call email, write something like: "At the end, if it's a fit, I'll ask whether you want to go ahead. A yes and a no are both fine." Someone who knows a decision is coming can do their thinking before the call. Our guide to raising your sales call show rate covers the emails between booking and the call.

What do you say when they need to talk to their partner?

On the call: Treat it as a fair reason. A program at this price can affect a whole household. Shopify's guide also notes that "Often, people give this excuse when they don't want to commit to a decision." One question tells you which it is: "What do you think they'll want to know?" Answer those questions now, so they can repeat the answers at home. Then offer a short call with both of you, and book it before you hang up.

Fix it upstream: Ask who else is part of the decision on the application form, and invite that person to the call. You hear the partner's questions first hand, not second hand after the call.

What do you say when the timing isn't right?

On the call: Find out if the timing is real. HubSpot says the job is "to figure out whether the timing concern is genuine or a brush-off". Ask: "What's happening between now and then that makes later better?" A launch, a house move, or a new baby are real reasons, and you can agree a date to talk again. If the answer is vague, ask what would have to change for now to work.

Fix it upstream: Ask on the form when they'd want to start and what made them apply now. Someone who writes "someday" hasn't decided this is urgent yet, and your emails can nurture them before you spend a call on them. The time between an application and the call is time for that reason to fade, and our guide to speed to lead covers the first reply after someone applies.

What do you say when they've tried this before?

On the call: Ask what happened, and listen: "What did you try, and where did it stop working?" Then say plainly what's different about how you work, tied to the reason it stopped last time. If your program has the same weak spot, say so and say how you'd handle it. Don't criticize the other coach. HubSpot lists derogatory comments about a competitor among the habits that "confirm a prospect's worst assumptions".

Fix it upstream: Ask what they've tried on the form, and send one piece before the call that shows how your program works week to week, such as a short video from you or a story from one of your own clients. Then the call starts from what's different instead of from defending your method.

What should you never say to push a sale through?

Anything that wins the yes by pressure instead of fit. HubSpot lists pressuring the prospect "by sowing fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD)" and reaching "for tired tactics like discounts or false claims" among the habits of underachieving reps. On a coaching call, leave these out.

Made-up deadlines. Shopify's retail guide suggests a limited time offer to create urgency. On a coaching call, only name a deadline that's real, like a cohort start date. A "today only" price that's back next week teaches people to wait.

Discounts after a no. A lower price for hesitating makes saying no the way to get a better deal.

Arguing. Correcting someone head-on puts them on the defensive. Acknowledge first, then ask.

Fear. Telling someone their life gets worse without you is pressure. Let them say what standing still costs them, in their own words, during discovery.

Selling to someone who can't pay. If they can't afford it without hardship, say so and end the call kindly.

How do you find which objection to fix first?

Record the objection from every call that didn't close as a tag in your email platform, then count the tags. The most common one points to the upstream step to fix first. Our email marketing guide for coaches maps every sequence around the call, so you can see where each fix lives.

Here's a worked example with made-up numbers. In a month, 20 people attend your calls and 4 buy, so your close rate is 4 divided by 20, or 20%. Of the 16 who didn't buy, 7 said price, and 5 of those 7 told you they hadn't set aside a budget. You add a budget question with ranges to your form, and those 5 people are no longer booked. The next month, the same 4 buy from 15 calls attended, a close rate of about 27%, and you have five calls' worth of time back.

Sales stayed the same. Close rate went up because fewer people who couldn't buy reached the call.

When does this not apply?

Offers sold on a checkout page. With no call, each objection needs an answer on your sales page, in your FAQ, and in your emails instead.

Referral calls. Someone a client sent may already know your price and how you work. Spend less time on objections and more on fit.

Prospects who can't afford it. No wording fixes that, and none should. Tell them, and point them to something smaller if you have it.

The same objection on every call. If every call ends the same way after you've fixed the upstream steps, the wording isn't the problem. Look at the offer, the price, and who your content attracts.

Where should you start?

Write down the objection from each of your last ten calls that didn't close. Pick the most common one, fix its upstream step, and use the four moves on your next calls.

Hayes Media's published case studies are eCommerce, and we haven't published results for coaches or info businesses, so treat this as mechanism and advice. If you want a second pair of eyes, we'll audit your application form, your pre-call email and SMS, and your post-call follow-up against these objections and mark the gaps. Book a discovery call. No onboarding fees. No lock-in contracts. No junior marketers.

Sources

HubSpot, Objection handling: 44 common sales objections & how to respond: https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/handling-common-sales-objections

Shopify, Sales Objections: 5 Common Examples and How to Handle Them: https://www.shopify.com/blog/sales-objections

Frequently asked questions

How do you handle sales objections on a coaching call?
Acknowledge the objection without arguing, ask one question to find the real concern, answer that concern in plain words, and agree a next step before the call ends: a yes, a no, or a booked time to talk again. Then note which step before the call could have raised it earlier, such as the application form or a pre-call email, and fix that step.
What should a coach say when a prospect says it's too expensive?
Ask whether it's the total amount or whether it's worth it for them. If it's the value, play back the goal they described and show which parts of the program get them there. If it's the amount, share any payment options you already offer. If they truly can't afford it, say now isn't the right time and don't push them toward a purchase.
How do you respond when a prospect says they need to think about it?
Say "No problem," then ask what part they want to think through. Their answer gives you a specific concern, such as price, timing, or a partner, that you can answer while you're both on the call. If they still want time, book a day and time to talk again before you hang up, and say in your pre-call emails that the call ends with a decision.
Should you offer a discount to close a coaching client on the call?
No. A price that drops when someone hesitates tells them the first price wasn't real, and it makes saying no the way to get a better deal. If price is the concern, explain what the program includes, offer payment options you already have, and say plainly if now isn't the right time. Use deadlines only when they're real, like a cohort start date.
What are the most common types of sales objections?
HubSpot groups sales objections into four types: budget, authority, need, and timing. On a coaching call those show up as price, "I need to talk to my partner," "I'm not sure it'll work for me," and "Now isn't the right time." "I need to think about it" can hide any of the four. Each one points to a step before the call that you can fix.
How do you stop the same objections coming up on every sales call?
Tag the objection from every call that didn't close and count the tags. Then fix the step before the call that should have raised it: a budget question on your application form for price, a question about who decides for partner objections, and a pre-call email that says the call ends with a decision for "I need to think about it."

Want this run for your brand?

Hayes Media builds direct response creative, buys the media, and runs the email & SMS behind it.

Book a discovery call

Keep reading